Elie Wiesel’s Open Heart, and Thoughts on Christian Suffering

In his memoir Open Heart, Elie Wiesel takes us through his experiences surrounding his 2011 open heart surgery.  Wiesel is famous for his Night trilogy, and here some of the same themes come back in short, fleeting chapters – the dark memories of life in Auschwitz and Buchenwald, as well as the perennial question: why does God allow His children to suffer evil?  What should a Jewish person’s response be in times of persecution or pain?  Question marks abound in this short work, underlining the great despair we may sometimes feel when evil touches our lives.

One reason I picked up this book was to understand something of what a patient experiences during this medical procedure.  My grandma has faced a myriad of health issues, including two heart surgeries; she endured them with grace even while she was in terrible pain.  What could she have been feeling?  I have never asked her, choosing instead (as with other personal questions) to seek another avenue of understanding in Wiesel’s book.

Of course, it is not an exact parallel.  For one thing, Wiesel’s perceptions or imaginings of the afterlife are not identical to Christian beliefs on the same.  He describes his picture of hell as “ruled by cruel, pitiless angels” and full of physical tortures.  In this book, he does not seek to systematically explain his beliefs, offer a treatise on death, or even describe the surgery in detail.  Instead, Wiesel presents his thoughts and reactions moving from one scene to the next – a surreal, metaphysical, and ultimately personal exploration.

I’ve mentioned before Shūsaku Endō’s book The Silence, one I’ve been actively avoiding (yet will ultimately read).  In Open Heart, Wiesel touches on the same theme – the apparent silence of God.

…Auschwitz is not only a human tragedy but also – and most of all – a theological scandal.  For me, it is as impossible to accept Auschwitz with God as without God.  But then how is one to understand His silence?

For Christians, too, this question is not irrelevant.  Many of my family members in Christ are enduring persecution as I write.  Barnabas Aid is a charity I support, and every day their prayer focus features a story of the horrifying, often government-sanctioned brutalization of Christians in other parts of the world.  The Armenian Genocide – which Wiesel worked to bring awareness to – is a historic example. On a personal level, each of us has suffered his or her own tragedy, be it a physical disease, a mental health struggle, the death or loss of a loved one, or something else which we may never tell another human being. 

Wiesel’s answer, in part, is as simple as the question: “Since God is, He is to be found in the questions as well as in the answers.”  There is certainly wisdom in acknowledging mystery.  Humanity itself involves mystery, from questions such as the Creation of the world and the beginning of a human’s soul, to those about the origin of evil and enduring hatred.

To add to this, it is no coincidence much of the New Testament covers the existence of persecution.  I’ve personally found comfort in the Gospel of John, where Jesus speaks to His disciples directly on this subject, with empathy:

If the world hates you, you know that it hated Me before it hated you. If you were of the world, the world would love its own. Yet because you are not of the world, but I chose you out of the world, therefore the world hates you.  (John 15:18–19, NKJV)

I wish there were words to adequately describe John 17 – epic or poetic seem trite.  But here, too, in His last prayers before death, Jesus speaks of His followers:

I do not pray for these alone, but also for those who will believe in Me through their word; that they all may be one, as You, Father, are in Me, and I in You; that they also may be one in Us, that the world may believe that You sent Me. And the glory which You gave Me I have given them, that they may be one just as We are one: I in them, and You in Me; that they may be made perfect in one, and that the world may know that You have sent Me, and have loved them as You have loved Me.  (John 17:20–23, NKJV)

Suffering remains something of a mystery to me.  Through my own experiences, though – which, while personally crushing, were minute compared to those of others – I can affirm God was never absent.  If even small struggles matter to Him, how much more so the greater ones.





12 responses to “Elie Wiesel’s Open Heart, and Thoughts on Christian Suffering”

  1. Brian Joseph Avatar

    Superb post. I have only read Night by Elie Wiesel and I feel that I need to move on to more of his works. Religious persecution is foul poison. In parts of the world it is Christians, Atheists, Muslims, other groups too. It is imperative that individuals and governments oppose it.


  2. Ruth Avatar

    I know Wiesel struggled with this very important question about God. I understood his pain in Night. I also read his autobiography All Rivers Run to the Sea. But this is one I have not heard of. I don't know if he ever did come to an understanding of Christ's suffering for him.


  3. Mudpuddle Avatar

    EW was a remarkable survivor… i haven't read him, as i try to evade the more miserable features of human existence, but i still respect the man for what he is and did…


  4. Marian H Avatar

    Same here, I have only read Night so far. I hope to re-read it soon, along with the other two books in the trilogy (Dawn and Day).


  5. Marian H Avatar

    Apparently he wrote over 50 books in total…I so admire authors who are willing to write about such personal topics, including their own questions.


  6. Marian H Avatar

    In this book, Wiesel does not go into detail about his experiences in the camps, so it's probably more accessible than Night in that regard. I have read very few Holocaust memoirs, to be honest… for example, I've been waiting years to read The Diary of Anne Frank. I guess it gives me more time to process each one.


  7. Ruth Avatar

    Wow, 50!? I barely scratched the surface.


  8. R. T. Davis Avatar

    The Book of Job has been an “answer” for me. In other words, the ineffable cannot be explained. And so it goes.https://rtdinformalinquiries.blogspot.com/


  9. Marian H Avatar

    Thanks, R.T. – I started re-reading Job today after seeing your comment. It's been a while since I last read it; maybe the time away will help me learn something new this time.


  10. Sharon Wilfong Avatar

    Hi Marion, I read Night because in Sunday School, the leader told us the back story. Wiesel went to interview a French writer who was also a priest. The priest went out of his way to share the gospel with him. Finally, Wiesel jumped up and told the priest he didn't know what he was talking about. And left.The priest ran after him and told him he must tell his story. So after several years of silence, he wrote \”Night\”.


  11. Marian H Avatar

    Wow, I did not know that!


  12. Thoughts on Christian Suffering – Conclusion – Classics Considered Avatar

    […] in 2018, I reviewed Open Heart by Elie Wiesel and, in the same post, expressed my frustration to understand the purpose of suffering, especially […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: